Sunday, October 5, 2008
Fear of Regret
the "fear of regret." People tend to feel sorrow and grief after having made an error in judgement. Investors deciding whether to sell a security are typically emotionally affected by whether the security was bought for more or less than the current price. One theory is that investors avoid selling stocks that have gone down in order to avoid the pain and regret of having made a bad investment. The embarrassment of having to report the loss to the IRS, accountants, and others may also contribute to the tendency not to sell losing investments. Some researchers theorize that investors follow the crowd and conventional wisdom to avoid the possibility of feeling regret in the event that their decisions prove to be incorrect. Many investors find it easier to buy a popular stock and rationalize it going down since everyone else owned it and thought so highly of it. Buying a stock with a bad image is harder to rationalize if it goes down. Additionally, many believe that money managers and advisors favor well known and popular companies because they are less likely to be fired if they underperform
Friday, October 3, 2008
Wall Street Crash of 1929
Cause: In the late 1920s, hundreds of thousands of investors contributed to a speculative bubble in the stock market. Many went into debt to purchase stock, resulting in more than $8.5 billion in debt throughout the nation—more money than was in circulation at the time.
When the market turned bearish on October 24, 1929, investors panicked, causing a massive selloff that tanked the stock markets and contributed to the Great Depression of the 1930s.
To demonstrate confidence in the market, the Rockefeller family and the heads of major banks bought large quantities of stock. This move didn’t stop the panic. During the week of October 24, the market lost a total of $30 billion, more than the United States had spent on World War I.
The stock market crashed caused businesses to close, mass layoffs, and a rash of bankruptcies. An international run on the dollar resulted in increased interest rates, driving out around 4,000 lenders.Action: After an investigation, Congress passed the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 (now repealed), mandating a separation between investment and commercial banks. They believed this would avert another dramatic panic sale. It didn’t—the Dow fell 22.6% in 1987—but, to date, the Great Depression that followed the 1929 crash hasn’t been repeated.
Moral of the story: Don’t panic. Many scholars now say that the 1929 crash didn’t cause the Great Depression, but certainly contributed to its severity. Public panic only makes situations worse than they already are
When the market turned bearish on October 24, 1929, investors panicked, causing a massive selloff that tanked the stock markets and contributed to the Great Depression of the 1930s.
To demonstrate confidence in the market, the Rockefeller family and the heads of major banks bought large quantities of stock. This move didn’t stop the panic. During the week of October 24, the market lost a total of $30 billion, more than the United States had spent on World War I.
The stock market crashed caused businesses to close, mass layoffs, and a rash of bankruptcies. An international run on the dollar resulted in increased interest rates, driving out around 4,000 lenders.Action: After an investigation, Congress passed the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 (now repealed), mandating a separation between investment and commercial banks. They believed this would avert another dramatic panic sale. It didn’t—the Dow fell 22.6% in 1987—but, to date, the Great Depression that followed the 1929 crash hasn’t been repeated.
Moral of the story: Don’t panic. Many scholars now say that the 1929 crash didn’t cause the Great Depression, but certainly contributed to its severity. Public panic only makes situations worse than they already are
Buffett's Ferocious Focus
For more than half a century Warren Buffett has shown impeccable timing. So perhaps it should come as no surprise that the first biography he has authorized was published in late September as news of the financial crisis that he had warned about dominated the front pages and just days after he had agreed to inject $5 billion into Goldman Sachs (GS).
Much of the legendary investor's story has been told, notably in Roger Lowenstein's masterful Buffett: The Making of an American Capitalist. But in The Snowball: Warren Buffett and the Business of Life, former Morgan Stanley (MS) insurance analyst Alice Schroeder provides a much more penetrating and personal look at the Oracle of Omaha.
Schroeder's portrait is the product of five years of research that included unprecedented access. She describes an obsessive man emotionally damaged by his mother's rages who nevertheless knew what he wanted and how to get there from an early age. Here readers will again encounter the burger-eating, Cherry Coke-swilling, aphorism-spouting outsider familiar from previous accounts. But The Snowball (to succeed, find wet snow and a really long hill, advises Buffett) is more perceptive than other works, getting deeply inside the head of the man who achieved such amazing long-term investment returns that some academics believe them to be a fluke.
Buffett himself has attributed his success to "focus." Schroeder writes: "He ruled out paying attention to almost anything but business—art, literature, science, travel, architecture—so that he could focus on his passion." As a child, Schroeder relates, Warren carried around a coin-changer as his prized possession, and when his dad offered him a trip at age 10, he asked to go to the New York Stock Exchange (NYX). Not long after, Buffett read a book called One Thousand Ways to Make $1,000 and announced to a friend that he was going to be a millionaire by the time he was 35. "That was an audacious, almost silly-sounding statement for a child to make in the depressed world of 1941," Schroeder writes. "But…he was sure he could do it."
And, of course, he did, and then some. After college, rejected from Harvard B-school, Buffett went to Columbia instead, where he studied under the legendary Benjamin Graham, author of The Intelligent Investor and the father of value investing. Buffett learned from Graham the perils of Mr. Market and how to know what companies were worth regardless of what the market claimed on a given day.
He started out buying "cigar butts," run-down companies with one puff left, and he ended up buying stock in some of the greatest brands in U.S. business, including Coca-Cola (KO) and Gillette (G), as well as private outfits such as the Nebraska Furniture Mart and See's Candies. At the core of Buffett's investing vehicle, Berkshire Hathaway (BRKA)—and the reason for Schroeder's first contact with him—are insurance operations, which have included GEICO and General Re. Highly profitable, these threw off more money for Buffett to invest.
Buffett's method, as learned from Graham and developed further on his own, was simple: Estimate the investment's value, handicap its risk, keep a margin of safety, and then let compounding do the real work. Through the go-go era of the '60s and the Internet bubble of the '90s, as others got caught up in mania, Buffett's philosophy didn't change. He bought only stocks that he could understand and value, and he wanted them cheap. "Anyone could understand these simple ideas," Schroeder writes, "but few could execute them."
Much of the legendary investor's story has been told, notably in Roger Lowenstein's masterful Buffett: The Making of an American Capitalist. But in The Snowball: Warren Buffett and the Business of Life, former Morgan Stanley (MS) insurance analyst Alice Schroeder provides a much more penetrating and personal look at the Oracle of Omaha.
Schroeder's portrait is the product of five years of research that included unprecedented access. She describes an obsessive man emotionally damaged by his mother's rages who nevertheless knew what he wanted and how to get there from an early age. Here readers will again encounter the burger-eating, Cherry Coke-swilling, aphorism-spouting outsider familiar from previous accounts. But The Snowball (to succeed, find wet snow and a really long hill, advises Buffett) is more perceptive than other works, getting deeply inside the head of the man who achieved such amazing long-term investment returns that some academics believe them to be a fluke.
Buffett himself has attributed his success to "focus." Schroeder writes: "He ruled out paying attention to almost anything but business—art, literature, science, travel, architecture—so that he could focus on his passion." As a child, Schroeder relates, Warren carried around a coin-changer as his prized possession, and when his dad offered him a trip at age 10, he asked to go to the New York Stock Exchange (NYX). Not long after, Buffett read a book called One Thousand Ways to Make $1,000 and announced to a friend that he was going to be a millionaire by the time he was 35. "That was an audacious, almost silly-sounding statement for a child to make in the depressed world of 1941," Schroeder writes. "But…he was sure he could do it."
And, of course, he did, and then some. After college, rejected from Harvard B-school, Buffett went to Columbia instead, where he studied under the legendary Benjamin Graham, author of The Intelligent Investor and the father of value investing. Buffett learned from Graham the perils of Mr. Market and how to know what companies were worth regardless of what the market claimed on a given day.
He started out buying "cigar butts," run-down companies with one puff left, and he ended up buying stock in some of the greatest brands in U.S. business, including Coca-Cola (KO) and Gillette (G), as well as private outfits such as the Nebraska Furniture Mart and See's Candies. At the core of Buffett's investing vehicle, Berkshire Hathaway (BRKA)—and the reason for Schroeder's first contact with him—are insurance operations, which have included GEICO and General Re. Highly profitable, these threw off more money for Buffett to invest.
Buffett's method, as learned from Graham and developed further on his own, was simple: Estimate the investment's value, handicap its risk, keep a margin of safety, and then let compounding do the real work. Through the go-go era of the '60s and the Internet bubble of the '90s, as others got caught up in mania, Buffett's philosophy didn't change. He bought only stocks that he could understand and value, and he wanted them cheap. "Anyone could understand these simple ideas," Schroeder writes, "but few could execute them."
When All Stocks Are Value Stocks - Think QDI (quality, diversification, income)
Article upon value stocks by Steve Selengut writer of "The Brainwashing of the American Investor: The Book that Wall Street Does Not Want YOU to Read", Enjoy the article it is really a fundoo one.....................
Value stocks are those that tend to trade at lower prices relative to their fundamental characteristics than their more speculative cousins, the growth stocks; they have higher than usual dividend yields and lower P/E and P/B ratios. So when all stock prices are down significantly, have they all become value stocks? Or, based on the panicky fear that tends to overwhelm media and financial experts alike, haven't they all taken on the speculative characteristics of growth stocks?
Well, to a certain extent they have, because the lower value stock prices go, the more likely it is that they will eventually experience the 15% ROE that typifies the classic growth stock. Interestingly, by definition, growth stocks are expected to be associated with profitable companies, a fact that speculators often lose site of. There are three features that separate value stocks from growth stocks and two that separate Investment Grade Value (IGV) stocks from the average, run-of-the-mill, variety.
Value stocks pay dividends, and have lower ratios than growth stocks. IGV stock companies also have long-term histories of profitability and an S & P rating of B+ or higher. Would you be surprised to learn that neither the DJIA nor the S & P 500 contains particularly high numbers of IGV stocks? Still, since 1982, value stocks have outperformed growth stocks 62% of the time. So when an ugly correction has a makeover, it's likely that all value stocks transform themselves into growth stocks, at least temporarily.
Will Rogers summed up the stock selection quandary nicely with: "Only buy stocks that go up. If they aren't going to go up, don't buy them." Many have misunderstood this tongue-in-cheek observation and joined the buy-anything-high investment club. You need dig no further than the current lists (June '08) of "most advancing issues" to see how investors are buying commodity companies and financial futures at the highest prices in the history of mankind.
This while they are shunning IGVSI (Investment Grade Value Stock Index) companies that have plummeted to their most attractive price levels in three to five years. Many of the very best multinational companies in the world are at historically low prices. Wall Street smiles knowingly (and greedily) as Main Street hucksters tout gold, currencies, and oil futures as retirement plan safety nets. Regulatory agencies look the other way as speculations worm their way into qualified plans of all varieties. Surely those markets will be regulated some day--- after the next Bazooka-pink, gooey mess becomes history.
How much financial bloodshed is necessary before we realize that there is no safe and easy shortcut to investment success? When do we learn that most of our mistakes involve greed, fear, or unrealistic expectations about what we own? Eventually, successful investors begin to allocate assets in a goal directed manner by adopting a more realistic investment strategy--- one with security selection guidelines and realistic performance definitions and expectations.
If you are thinking of trying a strategy for a year to see if it works, you're being too short-term sighted--- the investment markets operate in cycles. If you insist on comparing your performance with indices and averages, you'll rarely be satisfied. A viable investment strategy will be a three-dimensional decision model, and all three decisions are equally important. Few strategies include a targeted profit taking discipline--- dimension two. The first dimension involves the selection of securities. The third?
How should an investor determine what stocks to buy, and when to buy them? We've discussed the features of value and growth stocks and seen how any number of companies can qualify as either dependent upon where we are in terms of the market cycle or where they are in terms of their own industry, sector, or business cycles. Value stocks (and the debt securities of value stock companies) tend to be safer than growth stocks. But IGVSI stocks are super-screened by a unique rating system that is based on company survival statistics--- very important stuff.
In the late 90's, it was rumored that a well-known value fund manager was asked why he wasn't buying dot-coms, IPOs, etc. When he said that they didn't qualify as value stocks, he was told to change his definition--- or else. IGV stocks include a quality element that minimizes the risk of loss and normally smoothes the angles in the market cycle. The market value highs are typically not as high, but the market value lows are most often not as low as they are with either growth or Wall Street definition value stocks. They work best in conjunction with portfolios that have an income allocation of at least 30%--- you need to know why.
How do we create a confidence building IGV stock selection universe without getting bogged down in endless research? Here are five filters you can use to come up with a listing of higher quality companies: (1) An S & P rating of B+ or better. Standard & Poor's combines many fundamental and qualitative factors into a letter ranking that speaks only to the financial viability of the companies. Anything rated lower adds more risk to your portfolio.
(2) A history of profitability. Although it should seem obvious, buying stock in a company that has a history of profitable operations is inherently less risky. Profitable operations adapt more readily to changes in markets, economies, and business growth opportunities. (3) A history of regular, even increasing, dividend payments. Companies will go to great lengths, and endure great hardships, before electing either to cut or to omit a dividend. Dividend changes are important, absolute size is not.
(4) A Reasonable Price Range. Most Investment Grade stocks are priced above $10 per share and only a few trade at levels above $100. An unusually high price may be caused by higher sector or company-specific speculation while an inordinately low price may be a good warning signal. (5) An NYSE listing--- just because it's easier.
Your selection universe will become the backbone of your equity asset allocation, so there is no room for creative adjustments to the rules and guidelines you've established--- no matter how strongly you feel about recent news or rumor. There are approximately 450 IGV stocks to choose from--- and you'll find the name recognition comforting. Additionally, as these companies gyrate above and below your purchase price (as they absolutely will), you can be more confident that it is merely the nature of the stock market and not an imminent financial disaster.
The QDI? Quality, diversification, and income.
Value stocks are those that tend to trade at lower prices relative to their fundamental characteristics than their more speculative cousins, the growth stocks; they have higher than usual dividend yields and lower P/E and P/B ratios. So when all stock prices are down significantly, have they all become value stocks? Or, based on the panicky fear that tends to overwhelm media and financial experts alike, haven't they all taken on the speculative characteristics of growth stocks?
Well, to a certain extent they have, because the lower value stock prices go, the more likely it is that they will eventually experience the 15% ROE that typifies the classic growth stock. Interestingly, by definition, growth stocks are expected to be associated with profitable companies, a fact that speculators often lose site of. There are three features that separate value stocks from growth stocks and two that separate Investment Grade Value (IGV) stocks from the average, run-of-the-mill, variety.
Value stocks pay dividends, and have lower ratios than growth stocks. IGV stock companies also have long-term histories of profitability and an S & P rating of B+ or higher. Would you be surprised to learn that neither the DJIA nor the S & P 500 contains particularly high numbers of IGV stocks? Still, since 1982, value stocks have outperformed growth stocks 62% of the time. So when an ugly correction has a makeover, it's likely that all value stocks transform themselves into growth stocks, at least temporarily.
Will Rogers summed up the stock selection quandary nicely with: "Only buy stocks that go up. If they aren't going to go up, don't buy them." Many have misunderstood this tongue-in-cheek observation and joined the buy-anything-high investment club. You need dig no further than the current lists (June '08) of "most advancing issues" to see how investors are buying commodity companies and financial futures at the highest prices in the history of mankind.
This while they are shunning IGVSI (Investment Grade Value Stock Index) companies that have plummeted to their most attractive price levels in three to five years. Many of the very best multinational companies in the world are at historically low prices. Wall Street smiles knowingly (and greedily) as Main Street hucksters tout gold, currencies, and oil futures as retirement plan safety nets. Regulatory agencies look the other way as speculations worm their way into qualified plans of all varieties. Surely those markets will be regulated some day--- after the next Bazooka-pink, gooey mess becomes history.
How much financial bloodshed is necessary before we realize that there is no safe and easy shortcut to investment success? When do we learn that most of our mistakes involve greed, fear, or unrealistic expectations about what we own? Eventually, successful investors begin to allocate assets in a goal directed manner by adopting a more realistic investment strategy--- one with security selection guidelines and realistic performance definitions and expectations.
If you are thinking of trying a strategy for a year to see if it works, you're being too short-term sighted--- the investment markets operate in cycles. If you insist on comparing your performance with indices and averages, you'll rarely be satisfied. A viable investment strategy will be a three-dimensional decision model, and all three decisions are equally important. Few strategies include a targeted profit taking discipline--- dimension two. The first dimension involves the selection of securities. The third?
How should an investor determine what stocks to buy, and when to buy them? We've discussed the features of value and growth stocks and seen how any number of companies can qualify as either dependent upon where we are in terms of the market cycle or where they are in terms of their own industry, sector, or business cycles. Value stocks (and the debt securities of value stock companies) tend to be safer than growth stocks. But IGVSI stocks are super-screened by a unique rating system that is based on company survival statistics--- very important stuff.
In the late 90's, it was rumored that a well-known value fund manager was asked why he wasn't buying dot-coms, IPOs, etc. When he said that they didn't qualify as value stocks, he was told to change his definition--- or else. IGV stocks include a quality element that minimizes the risk of loss and normally smoothes the angles in the market cycle. The market value highs are typically not as high, but the market value lows are most often not as low as they are with either growth or Wall Street definition value stocks. They work best in conjunction with portfolios that have an income allocation of at least 30%--- you need to know why.
How do we create a confidence building IGV stock selection universe without getting bogged down in endless research? Here are five filters you can use to come up with a listing of higher quality companies: (1) An S & P rating of B+ or better. Standard & Poor's combines many fundamental and qualitative factors into a letter ranking that speaks only to the financial viability of the companies. Anything rated lower adds more risk to your portfolio.
(2) A history of profitability. Although it should seem obvious, buying stock in a company that has a history of profitable operations is inherently less risky. Profitable operations adapt more readily to changes in markets, economies, and business growth opportunities. (3) A history of regular, even increasing, dividend payments. Companies will go to great lengths, and endure great hardships, before electing either to cut or to omit a dividend. Dividend changes are important, absolute size is not.
(4) A Reasonable Price Range. Most Investment Grade stocks are priced above $10 per share and only a few trade at levels above $100. An unusually high price may be caused by higher sector or company-specific speculation while an inordinately low price may be a good warning signal. (5) An NYSE listing--- just because it's easier.
Your selection universe will become the backbone of your equity asset allocation, so there is no room for creative adjustments to the rules and guidelines you've established--- no matter how strongly you feel about recent news or rumor. There are approximately 450 IGV stocks to choose from--- and you'll find the name recognition comforting. Additionally, as these companies gyrate above and below your purchase price (as they absolutely will), you can be more confident that it is merely the nature of the stock market and not an imminent financial disaster.
The QDI? Quality, diversification, and income.
Monday, September 22, 2008
One should fearful in the market, It pays
nifty is almost 40% down from the high and dont ask about the sector specific stock like realty sector It is down about 70%!!! I know now a days who all are remain invested since the peak of market dont want to look into their portfolio......... Out of sight out of mind this simple psychology works here...
But the main point is when market started cracking we should have behaved like a fearful person. At least by acting fearfully and getting out of the market on the first run had saved our hard earned money.
Imagine If you are in the jungle alone with no arms to defend youself and suddenly you have the feeling that there might be a predator here what you will do ----- will you wait for the predator to come out from the bush when you get confirmed yes he is there then you run away? certainly not you wont wait for a moment to confirm that you will on run for your life without confirming about the predator. After all cost of runing even there is no predator is less then that of you only run when yo got confirmed he is there is very less.
So on the line of this natural fearful human behaviour we should have get out of the market when it was started slipping without waiting for the confirmation that yes certainly there is something wrong with the economy.....................
But the main point is when market started cracking we should have behaved like a fearful person. At least by acting fearfully and getting out of the market on the first run had saved our hard earned money.
Imagine If you are in the jungle alone with no arms to defend youself and suddenly you have the feeling that there might be a predator here what you will do ----- will you wait for the predator to come out from the bush when you get confirmed yes he is there then you run away? certainly not you wont wait for a moment to confirm that you will on run for your life without confirming about the predator. After all cost of runing even there is no predator is less then that of you only run when yo got confirmed he is there is very less.
So on the line of this natural fearful human behaviour we should have get out of the market when it was started slipping without waiting for the confirmation that yes certainly there is something wrong with the economy.....................
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Are You Lazy Thinker
A very good article It has enlighten my thought process....... superb......................
Few things make more of a difference in investing than thought process. Unlike most competitions, the primary battleground for investing is the mind. Investors must deal with an obstacle course of emotions, psychology, temperament, and other forces acting to overwhelm rational thought...................
Investing incentives are such that everyone plays the game with the intention of maximizing his or her wealth. Thus when people ask how to become a better investor, I often wonder how they feel about improving their thought process.
Without conscious effort our mind drifts towards weak thinking. Rarely do we, in good faith, see the opposing side of an argument. Of course we see the flaws in the argument.
If someone tells me that that Buffett was not the best investor over the last 40 years my initial reaction is what the heck are you smoking? Immediately my mind jumps to the flaws in his argument rather than trying to actually understand the opposing argument. I have prejudged this argument in my mind.
The inability to change your mind, destroy your ideas, or learn new mental-models will ensure that you are not constant winner in investing. Unable to discern the difference between a logical and illogical argument you will fall victim to sophists. According to Wikipedia, a sophism is a confusing or illogical argument used for deceiving someone. This means, in a sense, you will fall victim to arguments regardless of whether there are obvious flaws in the thinking behind them.
Strong thinkers, on the other hand, tend to be open-minded. Despite the natural desire to ignore opposing viewpoints, they seek to understand the arguments of others. It’s impossible to make informed decisions without a complete understanding of the opposing point of view. Understanding your opponents viewpoint better than him, according to Charlie Munger, ensures you make informed decisions.
Intellectual humility ensures you know what you do not. In investing circles, this is often referred to as circle of competence. Are you aware of all of your own false beliefs, prejudices, illusions, myths? Do you know how your mind goes about self-deception? Admitting your lack of knowledge in an area is very humbling. It helps ensure that beliefs can no longer be cemented in your head, but rather held only until contrary information appears. This all sounds very simple and it is. But, as Buffett teaches us, simple does not mean easy.
How often have you watched the news and made up your mind about some suspected criminal? I can’t count the number of times I have heard the tale of a graphic murder or rape and thought horrible things about the person held in custody. Yet this person is a suspect, convicted of nothing. Overcome by the graphic and often egregious nature of the crimes, my mind has rushed to form a judgment without any evidence. Only after taking a step back do i realize the error in my thinking.
Making snap-judgments without understanding the other side of an argument is weak thinking. Unfortunate as it may be, this thought process is easily rationalized and further cemented in our head. For example, in the case mentioned above, suppose the suspect turns out to be guilty – now the next time I come across a similar pattern in life I can easily recall the last time I made a snap judgment in a similar situation and I was right. This leads to overconfidence.
According to Richard W. Paul and Linda Elder, authors of Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Professional and Personal Life, the opposite of confidence in reason is intellectual distrust of reason, given by the threat that reasoning and rational analysis pose to the undisciplined thinker. Often volatility in stock markets is an emotional reaction from people who are not, at the time, using their strong thinking skills. Being prone toward emotional reactions that validate present thinking, people often express little confidence in reason.
A great example of how this can be used to manipulate us is by creating a culture where it’s difficult to argue with a point of view for emotional reasons. Consider the war in Iraq. If you denounce it you are no longer a patriot. If you question it you are no longer a patriot. The fear or war and terrorism plays with your head and you no longer think rationally and emotions take over. Consider our post on where the US spends money. It is infinitely more likely as an American you will die because of (presumably curable) cancer than a terrorist attack. Yet the government spends pennies on cancer while allocating trillions toward war efforts. Politics aside, is that rational?
In order to become a stronger thinker you have to challenge your existing beliefs. Or, inverted, in order to become a weaker thinker you must never challenge any of your beliefs. Sounds harsh doesn’t it? Can you identify one belief that you hold that might be wrong or questionable at best? It might be something simple like Starbucks has the best coffee. Buddhism is the best religion.
Are you willing to hold a different opinion in the face of adversity? The Asch conformity experiments suggest that this might be more difficult than we think. Peer pressure (social influence) plays a large role in how we behave and make decisions.
A new book, The opposable mind, suggests that rather than focusing on what successful leaders do we need to emulate and understand how they think. The author, Roger Martin, argues that integrative thinking is necessary. Martin describes this as creatively resolving the tension in opposing models by forming entirely new and superior ones. I see this as being able to hold opposing views in your mind at the same time.
Think to the last board meeting you attended at work. Remember that project being presented? When the presenter was light up with questions at the end did she distort the questioner’s point of view? Try reading a split decision handed down from the Supreme Court. ( Canadian and American Supreme Court decisions).Can you follow both opposing sides of the arguments? Or do you tend to agree with one side and discount the other side of the argument? What about a stock? Can you identify and understand both the bull and the bear case for a particular company? Can you follow both sides of an argument and yet, still have no opinion?
I used to identify flaws in corporate presentations and think to myself “wow, I’d never say that!” or “he really didn’t think that problem through”. Then I realized that I make all of these mistakes as well. You could call my behavior intellectual hypocrisy. As we noted in our presentation it’s relatively easy to think up the correct models, however implementing them is the challenge. (Checklists help. Imagine a pilot without a checklist!).
In a similar way, my lazy thinking was ensuring I didn’t act according to my beliefs. This can, and will, easily destroy your credibility. I find myself questioning certain policies that reward people for the right outcome rather than thought process, yet I am guilty of the same error on occasion. ( As I have learned, there is a huge difference between being right for the right reasons and right for the wrong reasons. Being right for the wrong reasons and having this behavior rewarded will eventually lead to horrible outcomes for horrible reasons. Try explaining those to your shareholders).
Do you see hypocrisy in your friends or a group you are a member of? Can you identify any instance where you don’t practice what you preach? Often I advise others that they should do what they love; yet I find it incredibly difficult to do that myself. I always have an easy rationalization to grasp onto should someone ask my why I’m not a full time business analyst (on that note, if anyone has a business analyst job open where I can telecommute please let me know!)
Are you a lazy thinker? It’s so easy for me to come up with examples of how lazy am in thinking that I’m embarrassed. One example is university physics. Bombarded with formulas that were both complex and frustrating I looked for an easy way out and found one. Another example, one where several of these weak thinking traps aggregated into an irritating experience, is attempting to read through a modern finance book. Not only does my mind, naturally want to not believe most of the information in the book, it finds the formulas needlessly complex. My eyes start to gloss over and my mind gets lazy – very lazy. I rationalize this behavior because I think, if these textbook authors are so smart, why are they writing textbooks! Then I realize that I need to understand the opposing viewpoint as frustrating and time consuming as that may be. Intellectual perseverance is often a good thing (and occasionally not!).
Can you stand alone in your thinking? Buffett puts it another way, ‘You’re neither right nor wrong because other people agree with you. You’re right because your facts are right and your reasoning is right - that’s the only thing that makes you right. And if your facts and reasoning are right, you don’t have to worry about anybody else.’ Having the intellectual ability to lack dependence on others for thinking or reasoning is an enormous advantage that can, if used correctly, lead to outperforming markets and, more importantly, increase the quality of your life.
I can say with a reasonably amount of certainty that at some point or another we all fall victim to the intellectual traps mentioned above. The traits of weak thinking are merely dimensions of our mind at work. It would be just as easy for me to give examples of where following these weak thinking practices paid off in spades for me (these are not habits I want reinforced).
On the surface, setting out to improve your thinking is a laudable goal that seems easy. Mentioning some of the above traits of weak thinking was also relatively easy – consciously attempting to change your thinking habits, recognizing your limitations, and knowing when you are deceiving yourself is rather difficult. Finding great thinkers and learning more about how they make decisions is one of my goals for 2008. Just yesterday, I caught myself in a meeting, wondering what Charlie Munger would say to a presentation like this and spontaneously chuckled out loud just a little.
Few things make more of a difference in investing than thought process. Unlike most competitions, the primary battleground for investing is the mind. Investors must deal with an obstacle course of emotions, psychology, temperament, and other forces acting to overwhelm rational thought...................
Investing incentives are such that everyone plays the game with the intention of maximizing his or her wealth. Thus when people ask how to become a better investor, I often wonder how they feel about improving their thought process.
Without conscious effort our mind drifts towards weak thinking. Rarely do we, in good faith, see the opposing side of an argument. Of course we see the flaws in the argument.
If someone tells me that that Buffett was not the best investor over the last 40 years my initial reaction is what the heck are you smoking? Immediately my mind jumps to the flaws in his argument rather than trying to actually understand the opposing argument. I have prejudged this argument in my mind.
The inability to change your mind, destroy your ideas, or learn new mental-models will ensure that you are not constant winner in investing. Unable to discern the difference between a logical and illogical argument you will fall victim to sophists. According to Wikipedia, a sophism is a confusing or illogical argument used for deceiving someone. This means, in a sense, you will fall victim to arguments regardless of whether there are obvious flaws in the thinking behind them.
Strong thinkers, on the other hand, tend to be open-minded. Despite the natural desire to ignore opposing viewpoints, they seek to understand the arguments of others. It’s impossible to make informed decisions without a complete understanding of the opposing point of view. Understanding your opponents viewpoint better than him, according to Charlie Munger, ensures you make informed decisions.
Intellectual humility ensures you know what you do not. In investing circles, this is often referred to as circle of competence. Are you aware of all of your own false beliefs, prejudices, illusions, myths? Do you know how your mind goes about self-deception? Admitting your lack of knowledge in an area is very humbling. It helps ensure that beliefs can no longer be cemented in your head, but rather held only until contrary information appears. This all sounds very simple and it is. But, as Buffett teaches us, simple does not mean easy.
How often have you watched the news and made up your mind about some suspected criminal? I can’t count the number of times I have heard the tale of a graphic murder or rape and thought horrible things about the person held in custody. Yet this person is a suspect, convicted of nothing. Overcome by the graphic and often egregious nature of the crimes, my mind has rushed to form a judgment without any evidence. Only after taking a step back do i realize the error in my thinking.
Making snap-judgments without understanding the other side of an argument is weak thinking. Unfortunate as it may be, this thought process is easily rationalized and further cemented in our head. For example, in the case mentioned above, suppose the suspect turns out to be guilty – now the next time I come across a similar pattern in life I can easily recall the last time I made a snap judgment in a similar situation and I was right. This leads to overconfidence.
According to Richard W. Paul and Linda Elder, authors of Critical Thinking: Tools for Taking Charge of Your Professional and Personal Life, the opposite of confidence in reason is intellectual distrust of reason, given by the threat that reasoning and rational analysis pose to the undisciplined thinker. Often volatility in stock markets is an emotional reaction from people who are not, at the time, using their strong thinking skills. Being prone toward emotional reactions that validate present thinking, people often express little confidence in reason.
A great example of how this can be used to manipulate us is by creating a culture where it’s difficult to argue with a point of view for emotional reasons. Consider the war in Iraq. If you denounce it you are no longer a patriot. If you question it you are no longer a patriot. The fear or war and terrorism plays with your head and you no longer think rationally and emotions take over. Consider our post on where the US spends money. It is infinitely more likely as an American you will die because of (presumably curable) cancer than a terrorist attack. Yet the government spends pennies on cancer while allocating trillions toward war efforts. Politics aside, is that rational?
In order to become a stronger thinker you have to challenge your existing beliefs. Or, inverted, in order to become a weaker thinker you must never challenge any of your beliefs. Sounds harsh doesn’t it? Can you identify one belief that you hold that might be wrong or questionable at best? It might be something simple like Starbucks has the best coffee. Buddhism is the best religion.
Are you willing to hold a different opinion in the face of adversity? The Asch conformity experiments suggest that this might be more difficult than we think. Peer pressure (social influence) plays a large role in how we behave and make decisions.
A new book, The opposable mind, suggests that rather than focusing on what successful leaders do we need to emulate and understand how they think. The author, Roger Martin, argues that integrative thinking is necessary. Martin describes this as creatively resolving the tension in opposing models by forming entirely new and superior ones. I see this as being able to hold opposing views in your mind at the same time.
Think to the last board meeting you attended at work. Remember that project being presented? When the presenter was light up with questions at the end did she distort the questioner’s point of view? Try reading a split decision handed down from the Supreme Court. ( Canadian and American Supreme Court decisions).Can you follow both opposing sides of the arguments? Or do you tend to agree with one side and discount the other side of the argument? What about a stock? Can you identify and understand both the bull and the bear case for a particular company? Can you follow both sides of an argument and yet, still have no opinion?
I used to identify flaws in corporate presentations and think to myself “wow, I’d never say that!” or “he really didn’t think that problem through”. Then I realized that I make all of these mistakes as well. You could call my behavior intellectual hypocrisy. As we noted in our presentation it’s relatively easy to think up the correct models, however implementing them is the challenge. (Checklists help. Imagine a pilot without a checklist!).
In a similar way, my lazy thinking was ensuring I didn’t act according to my beliefs. This can, and will, easily destroy your credibility. I find myself questioning certain policies that reward people for the right outcome rather than thought process, yet I am guilty of the same error on occasion. ( As I have learned, there is a huge difference between being right for the right reasons and right for the wrong reasons. Being right for the wrong reasons and having this behavior rewarded will eventually lead to horrible outcomes for horrible reasons. Try explaining those to your shareholders).
Do you see hypocrisy in your friends or a group you are a member of? Can you identify any instance where you don’t practice what you preach? Often I advise others that they should do what they love; yet I find it incredibly difficult to do that myself. I always have an easy rationalization to grasp onto should someone ask my why I’m not a full time business analyst (on that note, if anyone has a business analyst job open where I can telecommute please let me know!)
Are you a lazy thinker? It’s so easy for me to come up with examples of how lazy am in thinking that I’m embarrassed. One example is university physics. Bombarded with formulas that were both complex and frustrating I looked for an easy way out and found one. Another example, one where several of these weak thinking traps aggregated into an irritating experience, is attempting to read through a modern finance book. Not only does my mind, naturally want to not believe most of the information in the book, it finds the formulas needlessly complex. My eyes start to gloss over and my mind gets lazy – very lazy. I rationalize this behavior because I think, if these textbook authors are so smart, why are they writing textbooks! Then I realize that I need to understand the opposing viewpoint as frustrating and time consuming as that may be. Intellectual perseverance is often a good thing (and occasionally not!).
Can you stand alone in your thinking? Buffett puts it another way, ‘You’re neither right nor wrong because other people agree with you. You’re right because your facts are right and your reasoning is right - that’s the only thing that makes you right. And if your facts and reasoning are right, you don’t have to worry about anybody else.’ Having the intellectual ability to lack dependence on others for thinking or reasoning is an enormous advantage that can, if used correctly, lead to outperforming markets and, more importantly, increase the quality of your life.
I can say with a reasonably amount of certainty that at some point or another we all fall victim to the intellectual traps mentioned above. The traits of weak thinking are merely dimensions of our mind at work. It would be just as easy for me to give examples of where following these weak thinking practices paid off in spades for me (these are not habits I want reinforced).
On the surface, setting out to improve your thinking is a laudable goal that seems easy. Mentioning some of the above traits of weak thinking was also relatively easy – consciously attempting to change your thinking habits, recognizing your limitations, and knowing when you are deceiving yourself is rather difficult. Finding great thinkers and learning more about how they make decisions is one of my goals for 2008. Just yesterday, I caught myself in a meeting, wondering what Charlie Munger would say to a presentation like this and spontaneously chuckled out loud just a little.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)